• Primitive Colonial Halloween 4” Jack O Lantern Pie Cut Out Pie Choice of Scent - The Primitive Pineapple Collection
  • Primitive Colonial Halloween 4” Jack O Lantern Pie Cut Out Pie Choice of Scent - The Primitive Pineapple Collection
  • Primitive Colonial Halloween 4” Jack O Lantern Pie Cut Out Pie Choice of Scent - The Primitive Pineapple Collection
  • Primitive Colonial Halloween 4” Jack O Lantern Pie Cut Out Pie Choice of Scent - The Primitive Pineapple Collection
  • Primitive Colonial Halloween 4” Jack O Lantern Pie Cut Out Pie Choice of Scent - The Primitive Pineapple Collection
1 6

Handmade in USA

Primitive Colonial Halloween 4” Jack O Lantern Pie Cut Out Pie Choice of Scent

$16.00
$16.00

FREE U.S. Shipping on orders $99+ (applies to most products).
Int'l VAT/duties not included. Not eligible for free shipping promos. Details here

    Shop the 🎄 Patty's 12 Days of Christmas Sale

    Enjoy 15% OFF with code MERRY15 from December 1–12.

    Please note: Discount applies to in-stock items only — Patty says she can't see the future (yet), so restocks aren't included.

    Not all items are eligible for Discount.

    📦 Shipping & Delivery Details

    Free Shipping: Orders $99+ ship free within the continental U.S.

    (Sorry, friends in Hawaii and Alaska — free shipping promos don’t apply there just yet!)

    Where We Ship: We currently ship throughout the United States, and Patty’s thrilled to now offer international shipping to select countries! 🌍

    Standard Handling Time: Most items ship within 3–7 business days.

    Special Handling: Some pieces — like our Byers’ Choice® collectibles — may require up to 10 business days for extra care and packaging.

    Need more info?

    👉 Visit our Shipping FAQs for details on carriers, tracking, and international rates.
    ♥️ Happiness Guarantee

    We want you to love your Primitive Pineapple treasures!

    If something isn’t quite right, simply contact us within 30 days and we’ll help make it right.

    • Most items can be returned in new, unused condition within 30 days of delivery

    • If an item arrives damaged or incorrect, we’ll take care of it right away

    • Custom, clearance, and seasonal pieces are final sale — we hope you understand 💛

    Because many of our items are handmade or one-of-a-kind, small variations are part of their charm.

    Need to start a return or learn more about what’s eligible?

    👉 Read our full Return Policy
    💬 Questions?

    Patty’s always happy to help! If you’re wondering about shipping, returns, or product details, you’ll likely find the answer here:

    👉 Visit our FAQs page

    Still can’t find what you need? Reach out anytime — we love hearing from you! 💌
    Primitive Colonial Halloween 4” Jack O Lantern Pie Cut Out Pie Choice of Scent - The Primitive Pineapple Collection
    Primitive Colonial Halloween 4” Jack O Lantern Pie Cut Out Pie Choice of Scent - The Primitive Pineapple Collection
    Primitive Colonial Halloween 4” Jack O Lantern Pie Cut Out Pie Choice of Scent - The Primitive Pineapple Collection
    Primitive Colonial Halloween 4” Jack O Lantern Pie Cut Out Pie Choice of Scent - The Primitive Pineapple Collection
    Primitive Colonial Halloween 4” Jack O Lantern Pie Cut Out Pie Choice of Scent - The Primitive Pineapple Collection

    Product Details

    This is a handcrafted 4” Jack O Lantern cut out pumpkin pie. Approx. 4" . Made from dough that is baked and sealed to last.

    Comes scented or unscented. Please indicate scent choice in notes or it will ship unscented. Choices are:

    Sweet Potato PiePumpkin PiePumpkin CrunchGingerbreadGingerbread Apple SauceApple CinnamonFruit CakeSnickerdoodleSpice CakeBrown Sugar and CinnamonOatmeal RaisinChocolate Chip CookieCinnamon Roll

    AS THIS IS A HANDMADE ITEM, IT MAY HAVE SLIGHT VARIATIONS


    The images shown are display suggestions. Final results may vary. Please note that only the background of the image has been edited.